With the Slip tool (Y), dragging a clip showed nothing until release. Now the Program monitor
shows the previous clip's Out, the new In and Out (large, side by side, with their source
timecodes) and the next clip's In while the drag runs, plus the offset as a signed timecode and in
frames ("Slip: +25 frames", red "at the media limit" when the media's end holds it back); the
Timeline shows the offset at the pointer. Release commits `timeline.slip`, Escape drops it.
- `timeline.slipPreview` (`engine::slip::preview`) runs `slip_linked`, the function
`timeline.slip` now calls too, on a copy of the sequence: the preview is the commit at every
delta, linked picture and sound clamped together (#529, #594), with no project change or undo
step.
- `panels::slip_monitor` draws with the Trim Monitor's `picture()`, each picture in its own
frame-server view (`FrameServer::request_in_view`, #2366), so a fast drag keeps about one decode
per picture waiting and the newest frame wins.
- The slipped sound's waveform slides on the Timeline while dragging.
- New strings in every full-interface catalog (de, es, fr, id, it, ja, ko, pt-br, ru, zh-cn); uk
is still a small catalog and shows them in English.
Builds on #2366 (frame-server views); #2365 (the `slip_together` i64::MIN fix) is on main.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
4.7 KiB
UI and interaction parity
Last reviewed: 2026-10-10 · Last updated: 2026-10-10 · Change: major (new file: tools, handles, panels, keyboard and feel against Premiere Pro 26.5.2, with the open UI issues) · Target: Adobe Premiere Pro 2026 (26.5.2, macOS)
How FilmCraft looks, feels and responds compared with Premiere: tools, on-screen handles, snapping,
nudging, modifier keys, shortcuts, drag behaviour, numeric entry, panels, context menus. Keyboard
detail is in keyboard.md, monitor view options in monitors.md.
Reference screenshots and behaviour notes are maintainer-local (plan/premiere/, never committed).
UI / UX dimension: ~60% ready, breadth ~88%, 120–200 h (target-app-parity.md). UI fidelity was compared with Premiere reference screenshots by the agents that built it; that comparison has not been repeated independently. The ready figure is pulled down by the volume of open interaction reports (about 40 of the 188 open issues).
Areas
| Area | Premiere | Ours | % | Open issues | Est. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Menus | 366 in-scope menu items | ~338 present (label diff, 92%) | 92% | spelling, Render and Replace, 5 workspaces | 10–20 h |
| Keyboard | Premiere default keyboard + editor | Premiere-compatible preset (143 keyboard-only commands; 39 cloud / absent-panel keys skipped with reasons), FilmCraft / FCP / Avid presets, editor | 90% | Ctrl chords (#256 fixed), modifier hints on Windows (#270 fixed) | 5–10 h |
| Timeline editing tools | Selection, Track Select, Ripple / Rolling / Rate Stretch, Razor, Slip / Slide, Pen, Hand, Zoom, Type | all present, trim modes, Trim Monitor, four-up Slip Monitor while slipping, dynamic trimming | 80% | deselect in empty space (#683), gap delete (#648, #668), clip stretch (#653), new tracks by dropping (#483), Escape cancels drag (#580 fixed), delete in timeline (#680, #404) | 30–50 h |
| Program monitor on-screen controls | Motion / Transform handles, mask handles, safe margins, guides, transparency grid | guides, rulers, safe margins, transparency grid, snapping, mask drawing; no transform handles (#639); Button Editor (+) does nothing (#431) | 55% | #639, #431 | 15–25 h |
| Effect Controls | property rows, keyframe area with zoom, divider, graphs, eyedroppers | rows, keyframes, value / velocity graphs, eyedropper (#518); missing keyframe zoom (#641, #645), draggable divider (#643), row lines (#640), Position curves (#448) | 60% | #412, #640–#645, #448 | 15–25 h |
| Panels and docking | 17 workspaces, dock / undock / float, drop zones | 11 workspaces, docking; rearranging windows reported missing (#493); multi-monitor floating windows (#466) | 60% | #493, #466 | 20–35 h |
| Project panel | List / Icon / Freeform, hover scrub, marquee | all three views, hover scrub, view presets, New Item and File > New land in the open bin (#4093); no marquee (#578), Freeform bins (#579), bins can't be left on Windows (#587), duplicate imports allowed (#356) | 75% | #578, #579, #587, #456 | 10–20 h |
| Timeline display | filmstrip thumbnails, waveforms, track heights, renaming, duplicate frame markers | clip thumbnails, waveforms, heights, duplicate frame markers; no continuous filmstrip (#614), no track rename (#654), wheel scroll in audio area (#400) | 70% | #614, #654, #400 | 8–15 h |
| Transitions | drag, resize, alignment, edit in Effect Controls | drag / select / resize (#503); settings and the transition's own timeline in Effect Controls, drag to slide or resize (#577), drag the cut to move it with the transition; no A/B previews with Start / End sliders | 70% | #577 | 5–10 h |
| Numeric entry and scrubbing | scrubbable hot text, typed values | scrubbable values, timecode scrub-edit (#576), Up/Down step a number while typing it (Shift x10, Cmd x0.1; #4094); audio clip mixer values cannot be typed (#481) | 80% | #481 | 3–6 h |
| Drag and drop | OS files into Project / Timeline, clipboard paste | OS drops into the timeline (#517); no clipboard paste of images / files (#611) | 70% | #519, #611 | 5–10 h |
| Theme and appearance | dark / light, brightness | dark / light / system (#505, #555) | 85% | macOS window controls (#637), Wayland title bar (#433), X11 scale (#457) | 5–10 h |
| Context menus | per panel and per item | most panels; check against Premiere not done | 70% | — | 5–10 h |
| Accessibility | screen reader partial, keyboard navigation | keyboard navigation; every widget has an automation id; no screen-reader support | 30% | — | 15–30 h |
Revision history
| Date | Change | Summary |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-10 | major | Created: UI areas against Premiere 26.5.2, menu label diff, keyboard parity from keyboard.md, open UI issues itemized |